Related Reviews

Bill Condon

• Dreamgirls (2006)
• Kinsey (2004)
• Gods and Monsters (1998)
• The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn, Part 2 (2012)
• The Fifth Estate (2013)
• Mr. Holmes (2015)
• Beauty and the Beast (2017)

Helen Mirren

• National Treasure: Book of Secrets (2007)
• The Queen (2006)
• Shadowboxer (2006)
• The Clearing (2004)
• Calendar Girls (2003)
• Inkheart (2009)
• Caligula (1979)
• State of Play (2009)
• The Last Station (2009)
• The Long Good Friday (1980)
• Red (2010)
• The Debt (2011)
• The Tempest (2011)
• Glee: The Complete Third Season (2011)
• Hitchcock (2012)
• The Hundred-Foot Journey (2014)
• Woman in Gold (2015)
• Trumbo (2015)
• Collateral Beauty (2016)

Ian McKellen

• X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
• The Da Vinci Code (2006)
• Asylum (2005)
• The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003)
• The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002)
• The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001)
• X2 (X-Men 2) (2003)
• Gods and Monsters (1998)
• Doctor Who: The Snowmen (2012)
• X-Men: Days of Future Past (2014)
• The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014)
• Mr. Holmes (2015)
• Beauty and the Beast (2017)
• All Is True (2018)

Jim Carter

• Red Riding (2010)
• Downton Abbey (2019)

The Good Liar

At one point in the new thriller The Good Liar, a character regards a pond and remarks, with a slight, smug smile, “Be careful. It’s deeper than it looks.” The line is meant as a commentary on character but also a literary self-congratulation. And that would be all well and good if the film had a well-crafted plot with fascinating characters and surprising twists. Instead, it has Helen Mirren and Ian McKellen, and for those of us who’d watch them read the phone book, The Good Liar comes uncomfortably close.

I’m being hard on The Good Liar because its pedigree promises more than the film can deliver. Along with its storied stars, Oscar-winner Bill Condon (director of Kinsey, Dreamgirls and Gods and Monsters, which starred McKellen) directs a script by playwright and screenwriter Jeffrey Hatcher (Stage Beauty and the McKellen-Condon collaboration Mr. Holmes). Unfortunately, the Nicholas Searle novel Hatcher adapts features a shopworn story with easily anticipated plot twists, resulting in a soggy and largely pointless exercise that gets by on its consummate cast and some witty dialogue.

The first signal that we’re in for shenanigans comes from the setting: 2009 London. Condon gets off to an amusing start as Roy Courtnay (McKellen) and Betty McLeish (Mirren) white-lie to each other on a dating website, followed by an ostensibly charming first date that cashes in on The Good Liar’s star power. We’re immediately privy to Roy’s true nature as a con artist. Working with his partner Vincent (Jim Carter of Downton Abbey), Roy takes easy-mark investors to the cleaners with shady schemes. Working over widows like Betty amounts to a side hustle for Roy, although a potentially lucrative one.

Betty presents as a near-perfect patsy. She’s wealthy, with a medical condition guaranteed to shorten her life and a weakness for Roy’s charms and false humility. There’s just one thing: her wary son Steven (Russell Tovey of Looking), who refuses to trust Roy and deplores how quickly his mother lets the stranger into her life. By faking a bum knee, Roy swiftly scores an invite to live in Betty’s spare room, and before long, he’s insinuated himself as her life partner, joining bank accounts in an offshore investment scheme abetted by Vincent and accompanying her on a holiday to Berlin.

The Good Liar proves watchable mostly for McKellen, who relishes the role with the most opportunities to play. Mirren’s reliably good, but she must bide her time along with the plot, until the tickety-boom detonation of The Good Liar’s implausible rug-puller. In the end, the story’s self-described “depth” amounts to pulp paperback hooey that pays mere lip service to actual depths of psychology and emotion, but Condon’s film at least includes exactly what it says on the tin: lots of McKellen and Mirren, two legends sharing the screen together for the first time.